KARMAYOGIN

 

 SRI AUROBINDO

 

CONTENTS

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions 17.7.1909/4

 

Facts and Opinions  24.7.1909/5

An Unequal Fight

 

The Indiscretions of Sir Edward

God and His Universe

 

The Demand for Co-operation

The Scientific Position

 

What Co-operation?

Force Universal or Individual

 

Sir Edward's Menace

Faith and Deliberation

 

The Personal Result

Our "Inconsistencies"

 

A One-sided Proposal

Good out of Evil

 

The Only Remedy

Loss of Courage

 

The "Bengalee" and Ourselves

Intuitive Reason

 

God and Man

 

 

 

Exit Bibhishan

 

The Doctrine of Sacrifice

The Right of Association (Speech)

 

College Square Speech

 

 

 

 

Facts and Comments 4.9.1909/11

 

Facts and Opinions 11.9.1909/12

The Kaul Judgment

 

Impatient Idealists

The Implications in the Judgment

 

The Question of Fitness

The Social Boycott

 

Public Disorder and Unfitness

The Law and the Nationalist

   
   

The Hughly Conference

The Hughly Resolutions

   

 

Facts and Opinions 18.9.1909/13

 

Facts and Opinions 25.9.1909/14

The Two Programmes

 

The Convention President

The Reforms

 

Presidential Autocracy

The Limitations of the Act

 

Mr. Lalmohan Ghose

Shall We Accept the Partition?

   
   

The Past and the Future

 

Facts and Opinions 2.10.1909/15

 

Facts and Opinions 9.10.1909/16

The Rump Presidential Election

 

The Apostasy of the National Council

Nation-Stuff in Morocco

 

The Progress of China

Cook versus Peary

 

Partition Day

     

Nationalist Organisation

 

Nationalist Work in England

An Extraordinary Prohibition

   

 

Facts and Opinions 16.10.1909/17

Gokhale's Apologia

The People's Proclamation

The Anusilan Samiti

The National Fund

 

Union Day

 

Facts and Opinions 6.11.1909/18

Mahomedan Representation

The Growth of Turkey

China Enters

The Patiala Arrests

The Daulatpur Dacoity

Place and Patriotism

The Dying Race

The Death of Senor Ferrer

The Budget

A Great Opportunity

Buddha's Ashes

Students and Politics

 

The Assassination of Prince Ito

The Hindu Sabha

 

Facts and Opinions 13.11.1909/19

 

Facts and Opinions 20.11.1909/20

House-Searches

 

A Hint of Change

Social Reform and Politics

 

Pretentious Shams

The Deoghar Sadhu

 

THE Municipalities and Reform

 

 

Police Unrest in the Punjab  

The Great Election

 

 

 

 

The ReformED COUNCILS

 

Facts and Opinions 27.11.1909/21

 

Facts and Opinions 4.12.1909/22

The Bomb Case and Anglo-India

 

The Lieutenant-Governor's Mercy

The Nadiya President's Speech

 

An Ominous Presage

Mr. Macdonald's Visit

 

Chowringhee Humour

 

 

The Last Resort

The Alipur Judgment

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions 11.12.1909/23

 

Facts and Opinions 18.12.1909/24

The United Congress

 

Sir Pherozshah's Resignation

The Spirit of the Negotiations

 

The Council Elections

A Salutary Rejection

 

British Unfitness for Liberty

The English Revolution

 

The Lahore Convention

Aristocratic Quibbling

 

 

 

 

The Moderate Manifesto

The Transvaal Indians

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions 25.12.1909/25

 

Facts and Opinions 1.1.1910/26

The United Congress Negotiations

 

The Perishing Convention

A New Sophism

 

The Convention President's Address

Futile Espionage

 

The Alleged Breach of Faith

Convention Voyagers

 

The Nasik Murder

 

 

Transvaal and Bengal

Creed and Constitution

 

 

To My Countrymen

 

National Education

 

Facts and Opinions 8.1.1910/27

 

Facts and Opinions 15.1.1910/28

Sir Edward Baker's Admissions

 

The Patiala Case

Calcutta and Mofussil

 

The Arya Samaj and Politics

The Non-Official Majority

 

The Arya Disclaimer

Sir Louis Dane on Terrorism

 

What is Sedition?

The Menace of Deportation

 

 

 

 

A Thing that Happened

A Practicable Boycott

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions 22.1.1910/29

 

Facts and Opinions 29.1.1910/30

Lajpatrai's Letters

 

The High Court Assassination

A Nervous Samaj

 

Anglo-Indian Prescriptions

The Banerji Vigilance Committees

 

House-Search

Postal Precautions

 

The Elections

Detective Wiles

 

 

 

 

The Viceroy's Speech

The  New Policy

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions 5.2.1910/31

 

Passing Thoughts 12.2.1910/32

The Party of Revolution

 

Vedantic Art

Its Growth

 

Asceticism and Enjoyment

Its Extent

 

Aliens in Ancient India

Ourselves

 

The Scholarship of Mr. Risley

 

 

Anarchism

The Necessity of the Situation

 

The Gita and Terrorism

The Elections

 

 

 

 

 

Facts and Opinions

Volume I - Nov. 27, 1909 - Number 21

The Bomb Case and Anglo-India

 

The comments of the Anglo-Indian papers on the result of the appeal in the Alipur case are neither particularly edifying nor do they tend to remove the impression shared by us with many thoughtful Englishmen that the imperial race is being seriously demoralised by empire. From the Englishman we expect nothing better, and in fact we are agreeably surprised at the comparative harmlessness of its triumphant article on the day after the judgment. Its reference to the nonsense about there being no sedition in India and no party of Revolution leaves our withers unwrung. We ourselves belong to a party of peaceful revolution, for it is a rapid revolution in the system of Government in India which is the aim of our political efforts, and it is idle to object to us that there have been no peaceful revolutions and cannot be. History gives the lie to that statement, whether it proceeds from Mr. Gokhale or from Anglo-India. We have also always admitted that there is a Terrorist party, for bombs are not thrown without hands and men are not shot for political reasons unless there is Terrorism in the background. All we have contended, — and our contention is not overthrown by the judgment in the Alipur appeal, which merely proves that the conspiracy was not childish, and by no means that it was a big or widespread organisation, — is that the attempt of the Anglo-Indian papers to blacken the whole movement, and especially the whole Nationalist Party, is either an erroneous or an unscrupulous attempt, and the disposition of the police to arrest every young Swadeshi worker as a rebel and a dacoit is foolish, wrong-headed, often dishonest, and may easily become fatal to the chances of a peaceful solution of the dispute between the Government and the people. The Englishman, however, represents a lower grade of intellect and refinement to which these considerations are not likely to present themselves. The

 

Page – 283


average respectable Englishman is better represented by the Statesman, and the one dominating note in the Statesman is that of regret that the Courts had to go through the ordinary procedure of the law and could not effect a swift dramatic and terror-striking vindication of the inviolability of the British Government. One would have thought that a nation with the legal and political traditions of the English people would have been glad that the procedure of law had been preserved, the chances of error minimised and the State still safeguarded; and that no ground had been given for a charge of differentiating between a political and an ordinary trial to the prejudice of the accused. It is evident, however, that the type of Englishman demoralised by empire and absolute power considers that, in political cases, the Law Courts should not occupy themselves with finding out the truth, but be used as a political instrument for vengeance and striking terror into political opponents.

 

The Nadiya President's Speech

 

We congratulate Mr. Aswini Banerji on the able and vigorous speech delivered by him as the President of the Nadiya Conference. He took up an attitude which was at once manly and free from excess or violence. For ourselves the first point we turned to was the pronouncement on the Reforms. We do not think the judgment of the country on this ill-conceived measure could have been put with greater truth and force than in the periods of good-humoured contempt and irony, scathing yet in perfectly good taste, in which Mr. Banerji disposed of the claims of the Reform Scheme to be a measure of popular self-government. If all public men take the same attitude, the day of a true measure of popular control will be much nearer than if we affect a qualified satisfaction with this political bauble. As Mr. Banerji forcibly pointed out, it does not provide for a popular electorate, it does not admit of the election of popular leaders, it does not create a non-Government majority, or, as we would add, even the reasonable possibility of a strong opposition on essential points. What has the country to do with a reformed Council stripped of these

 

Page – 284


essentials ? The Jo-hookums, the self-seekers, the nonentities who wish to take advantage of the exclusion of distinguished and leading names in order to enjoy, at the expense of the country's interests, the kudos and substantial advantages of a seat on the Councils will scramble for the newly-created heaven; that is the kind of co-operation which the Government will get from the non-Mussulman part of the nation under this scheme. The country remains sullen and dissatisfied.

 

Mr. Macdonald's Visit

 

The tour undertaken by Mr. Ramsay Macdonald in India has been cut short by the call from England summoning him home to take his part in the great struggle which is the beginning of the end of Conservative and semi-aristocratic England. In the peaceful revolution which that struggle presages and in which it must sooner or later culminate, Mr. Macdonald's party stands to be the final winners. It is the semi-Socialistic Radical element in the Ministry attracted toward the Labour party to which the precipitation of this inevitable struggle is due. The Labour party is now predominatingly Socialistic and is purging itself of the old individualistic leaven which looked forward to no higher ideal than an eight-hours day, Old Age pensions and Trade Union politics. The Labour members, Messrs. Burt and Fenwick, who represent this old-world element, have received notice to quit from the Labour organisations which helped them into Parliament and much nonsense of a kind familiar to ourselves is being talked about the ingratitude of Labour to these veterans. The only justification for the existence of these gentlemen in Parliament is that they stand for the new insurgent demos and, if they cannot keep pace with the advancing sentiment of the people who keep them in Parliament, their duty is to retire, and the ingratitude is theirs if they try to hamper the progress of their life­long supporters by fighting the representatives of the new aspirations in the interests of a middle-class party. Mr. Macdonald belongs to the new thought, but he is, we believe, one of those who would hasten slowly to the goal. He has not the rugged

 

Page – 285


personality of Mr. Keir Hardie, but combines in himself, in a way Mr. Hardie scarcely does, the old culture and the new spirit. He has as broad a sympathy and as penetrating an intelligence as Mr. Nevinson, but not the latter's quick intensity. Nevertheless, behind the slow consideration and calm thoughtfulness of his manner, one detects hidden iron and the concealed roughness of the force that has come to destroy and to build, some hint of the rugged outlines of Demogorgon, the claws of Narasingha. For everyman is not only himself, he is that which he represents. Mr. Macdonald has been reserved and cautious during his visit and has spoken out only on the Reforms and Reuter, nor have his remarks on these subjects passed the limits of what any sincere Liberal would hold to be a moderate statement of the truth. Mr. Macdonald is one who does not speak out the whole of himself, he is a politician born, and born politicians do not care to outpace by too great a stride the speedily accomplishable fact. Whatever wider vistas they may see beyond, they prefer to move steadily towards them rather than to speak of them. So far as an Englishman can help India, and that under present circumstances is hardly at all, he certainly wishes to help. It is not his fault that the blindness of his countrymen and the conditions of the problem in India make men like him, perforce, little better than sympathetic spectators of the passionate struggle between established privilege and a nation in the making that the world watches now in India.

 

Page – 286